Let’s See How Artificial Intelligence Handles Trumpet Related Questions

Question #1
Who are the top 10 trumpet players in the world?
Response

“It is difficult to definitively rank the top 10 trumpet players in the world, as this is subjective and depends on personal taste and criteria. However, some highly regarded trumpet players who are frequently mentioned in discussions of the best include:
1.Wynton Marsalis
2.Dizzy Gillespie
3.Louis Armstrong
4.Freddie Hubbard
5.Miles Davis
6.Clifford Brown
7.Lee Morgan
8.Arturo Sandoval
9.Roy Hargrove
10.Clark Terry
This list is not exhaustive and there are many other talented trumpet players worth mentioning, including Phil Woods, Tom Harrell, and Nicholas Payton. The trumpet world is full of incredibly talented musicians, and the best way to discover your own favorites is to listen to a wide range of players and explore different styles and genres of music”.

Notice the question was directed towards the top 10 Trumpet “players” in the world. The response listed ten of the most recognized musicians on the internet, all of whom are or were, “Jazz” players. Also obvious is the fact that all of those listed, with the exception of Wynton Marsalis and Arturo Sandoval, are dead.
The top 10 Trumpet “players” in the world was also slanted towards only Jazz players of the past and excluded all of the wonderful Jazz players of today of which there are many.

Question #2
Who are the top 10 Orchestral trumpet players in the world?
Response

“It is difficult to definitively rank the top 10 orchestral trumpet players in the world, as this is subjective and depends on personal taste and criteria. However, some highly regarded orchestral trumpet players who are frequently mentioned in discussions of the best include:
1.Alison Balsom
2.Håkan Hardenberger
3.Thomas Stevens
4.Roger Ingram
5.Reinhold Friedrich
6.Gabriel Dobner
7.Jens Lindemann
8.Guy Touvron
9.Sergei Nakariakov
10.Tine Thing Helseth
This list is not exhaustive and there are many other talented orchestral trumpet players worth mentioning, including Hakan Hardenberger, Malte Burba, and Maurice Andre. The trumpet world is full of incredibly talented musicians, and the best way to discover your own favorites is to listen to a wide range of players and explore different styles and genres of music”.

Notice that my question as to the top “Orchestral” Trumpet players prompted a response listing not “Orchestral” Trumpet players but Trumpet “virtuoso” players. As we all know, the words “Orchestral” and “Virtuoso” are miles apart.

Question #3
Who are the top 10 orchestral Trumpet players of all time?
Response

“It is difficult to definitively rank the top 10 orchestral trumpet players of all time, as this is subjective and depends on personal taste and criteria. However, some highly regarded orchestral trumpet players who are frequently mentioned in discussions of the best include:
1.Adolf Herseth
2.Renold Schilke
3.Rafael Mendez
4.William Vacchiano
5.Armando Ghitalla
6.Roger Voisin
7.Raymond Mase
8.Tom Stevens
9.Malcolm McNab
10.Phil Smith
This list is not exhaustive and there are many other talented orchestral trumpet players from the past who made significant contributions to the instrument and the music world. It’s worth noting that the skills and musicianship of these players have been highly influential and set a high bar for future generations of orchestral trumpet players”.

This also brings up an interesting view of the evaluation process in Virtual Reality in that most of the players are true legends of Orchestral players, the inclusion of Rafael Mendez (one of the greatest virtuosi of all time) begs more scrutiny also.

So, in conclusion we have decided as have many others, that Artificial Intelligence is to be respected but does not warrant the seal of approval when it comes to an informed, fully developed and unbiased source of information on any topic other than the importance of Artificial Intelligence itself. Obviously personal egos are present in everything; artificial as well as real.

Bruce was a member of the faculty at the University of Northern Iowa, School of Music in Cedar Falls from 1969 until his retirement in 1999. He has performed with many well-known entertainers such as Bob Hope, Jim Nabors, Roy Rogers and Dale Evans, Steve Lawrence and Eydie Gorme, Anita Bryant, Carman Cavalara, Victor Borgie, the Four Freshman, Blackstone the Magician, Bobby Vinton and John Davidson.

2 thoughts on “Let’s See How Artificial Intelligence Handles Trumpet Related Questions

  1. Oz

    When the question is “who are” the top ten trumpet players in the world. I would think the questioner is
    referring to the players that are currently alive…Those that are now deceased are “not” in the top ten that are still live and playing today…So the AI needs to address a question asked in this manner to reflect those entities that “are” today…

  2. Bruce Chidester

    It really depends on the meaning of “is”, according to past presidents.

Comments are closed.