I’m sure that I have your attention at this time for a statement like that should raise the hackles on any musician worth their weight in valve oil.
For several months I have had the pleasure of performing with an exception troupe of actors (actresses) from New York who every day amaze me with their ability to “sell” there lines. Each performs at an amazing consistency and polished level of their art which humbles me when comparing it to the mere notes I play during each show.
Some may question my enthusiasm for these talented performers and some may even question my loyalty to my own craft, but after viewing these amazing professionals, I must admit, they are more prepared for their stage performance than any instrumentalist I have ever worked with and for that reason, I decided to compare their product and preparation with the product of instrumentalists.
I believe there are at least 3 reasons why actors and actresses are better prepared for their performance than are their instrumental counterparts.
Reason #1.
Actors and actresses are better at selling their product because of the following elements-
Thespians
Words
Facial expressions
Hand gestures
Body language
Posture
Tempo
Dynamics
Emphasis on words and syllables
Pronunciation
Timing
Reaction to previous lines
Breath
Costumes and makeup
Instrumentalists
Notes
Dynamics
Articulation
Wow! That even surprised me!
Reason #2.
Actors and actresses have an advantage over instrumentalists for the following reasons-
• Their text is based on known facts and related story lines which convey real life actions and experiences.
• Their performance is generally reinforced by a continued conversation with another actor (actresses) which adds continuity to the performance.
• Many times the application of costumes gives their performance more realism and authenticity.
• Each line adds reinforcement to the overall plot of the story.
• Each character represents an actual person who the audience is able to understand and relate to.
Reason #3.
Actors and actresses are better prepared than instrumentalists
Due to the previously listed advantages that actors (actresses) have over instrumentalists, more time is required to perfect their art. Not only are they expected to produce a convincing portrayal of their character, they are also expected to interact with their fellow performers on stage in order to give continuity, flow and perform in a convincing portrayal to their audience.
Many hours are spent on the small details required to represent their character on stage. They have refined through many hours of trial and error the very best way to get the most out of every word, line and expression as well as the best interplay with their fellow actors (actresses) on stage.
What amazes me the most when observing these incredible actors (actresses) in a show such as ours is the consistency with which each has been able to bring to the stage. Every line has been refined in order to get the most out of every word and syllable and every performance, to my ear, seems to be the same each and every show. This is the sign of true artistry.
As an incentive to our orchestra, I place a five dollar bill on my stand and challenge my fellow musician by saying, “Five dollars to anyone who can play a perfect show”! To this day, no one has been able to collect the money.
My opening title reads “3 Reasons why Actors are Better than Musicians”. Perhaps I should restate that by saying that actors (actresses) are better prepared than instrumentalists. Even qualifying this statement brings into question of which of the two is better at their art.
I encourage my instrumental colleagues to reply as I know you will to my observations for I am aware that I have touched on a nerve in many of you.
